Why is Red Gold a Social Enterprise?
Our business Red Gold of Afghanistan aims to empower women by purchasing, marketing, and selling Afghan saffron.
Early on in the business, we decided that Red Gold of Afghanistan would be a social enterprise instead of a charity. We wanted to use this post to talk about the benefits of the social enterprise model over a charity based model, in hopes that others going through the same decision-making process will have a reference point.
What is the difference between a charity and a social enterprise?
"Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day, teach a man to fish and you feed him for lifetime"
The differences in the models can be best summarized in this cliche. Coming from a rich developed country, the wealthy businesswoman has the power and choice to help this hungry fisherman however she wants.
A charity would use this position of power to be generous. She would generously give the fisherman fish! One fish, ten fish, a truckload of fish, regardless the man would have a good meal for the next little bit.
A social enterprise would use this power to teach the fisherman to fish, then buy his surplus fish to sell elsewhere. The woman might take the time to teach the whole village to fish too. The man may not get instant gratification for his hunger, but over a long period of time, he will be able to support himself, support his family, and support his village. In time, he may choose to take his expertise and teach other villages how to fish also.
We can see that both a charity and a social enterprise have a social objective related to them. Feed the fisherman.
However, their approaches are very different, and these little differences have long term consequences.
Looking at this story, with a charitable approach, there are a few problems.
- The donated fish will eventually run out
- What if you gave too much fish? So much, that a lot of them end up rotting
- The fisherman will not have to fish for a long time, he will be rusty. If it was his business and source of income, then he will not be making any money. Who wants to pay for fish when there is so much free fish for everyone?
- The fisherman is not helping anyone else. The source of fish he can share is limited.
- Eventually, the business woman will have to come back with another load of fish.
With the social enterprise approach, we can address some of these problems:
- The fisherman will be able to catch more fish
- The fisherman will likely catch as much fish as he needs, not significantly more
- The fisherman will always be fishing, making sure his skills are up to date and that he will be maintaining or growing his business
- Knowledge compounds and can be shared, the fisherman can take his skills and teach other people how to fish also!
- The businesswoman does not need to constantly provide fish, freeing her resources to help others. If she wants, she can buy a nice mackerel from the fisherman for her family.
A social enterprise is almost exactly like a normal business, with a focus on gaining profits. The only nuance is that the success of the venture is not solely measured on profits. The owners of the business also track the social impact that is being created.
Some example of these social goals may be to:
- Pounds of food saved from the landfill
- Number of children educated
- Number of water wells created
Instead of asking always, “what is going to make us the most money”, the question becomes “what is going to let us make the highest long term impact”. Often times, those two objectives line up very well in the long term.
For us, the key difference between a charity and a social enterprise boils down to sustainability. Social enterprises are built to stand alone and grow without significant external help.
- Profits fund your ability to continue making a difference, it is a sustainable business
- Working with local stakeholders lets you build solutions that work for them
- There can be a compounding effect, over time you can continue growing and making an impact
- Profits attract investors, who are much more willing to give you money to continue growing your project.
Charities are notoriously dependent on external funding. Unfortunately, governments change, donors pull out, and there are so many charities asking for attention. For those in Ontario, the election of the Ford government resulted in funding cuts for many NGO’s across the province.
The story of TOMS - Good Intentions, Poor Results
Many of you may know the story of TOMS shoes. They built their success off a unique model - for every pair of TOMS shoes that were bought in the US, the company would donate a pair of shoes to a child in a poor country like Haiti.
When I first heard about this many years ago, I (and many others) had the impression that this was a fantastic business model. By choosing to purchase, I would be directly benefiting a child! So what’s the problem?
In a simple system, where a problem can be easily identified and solved, TOMS would have succeeded. What they were proposing was simple. If you give shoes to children in Africa, you will improve their quality of life.
Unfortunately, the world is a complex system. There are a lot of moving parts, and when you have an initiative like TOMS shoes, actions with good intentions may have unintended consequences.
First did they have the impact that they were looking to have? The answer is a resounding no. One article from Harvard Political Review put it simply: “Is donating shoes an effective way of aiding impoverished communities when an estimated 800 million people worldwide lack access to basic nutrition?”
The problem gets worse.
Giving shoes put local shoemakers out of business. Their products were a replacement to previous pairs of locally made shoes, making it so that people purchased fewer shoes from local business owners. This meant that local manufacturers and the workers they employ were out of jobs.
Here we cannot make the argument of “doing something is better than nothing” when the donation of shoes actually led to a net negative overall impact. They have since revamped their charitable donation model to focus on higher impact activities such as helping communities with vision care.
Sustainably Solving Complex Systems
The world is full of complex systems, an environment with many different components which may interact with each other - sometimes unpredictably. Pull-on one thread, who knows what will happen to the rest?
For us, TOMS illustrates how well-intentioned actions in a complex system can have negative unintended consequences. Problems in this world are rarely as simple as they may seem from a classroom, which is why it is critical to work with local stakeholders and gain a deep understanding of the problem before prescribing over-simplified fixes.
Charities who truly engage with stakeholders are good at working with complex problems, and they have their place in the world. We especially admire the work of organizations such as the Bill-Melinda Gates Foundation, Canadian Red Cross, and countless others.
Here’s the thing. We are not Bill and Melinda Gates, who have a net worth of 107.1 billion USD. Funding and sustainability of their charitable organization is not a problem.
As much as we want to have 107.1 billion under our couch, the unfortunate reality is that we don’t have that amount of funding.
Our mission is to empower Afghan women to be financially independent. If we went the charity route, that means that we would have to spend a lot of our time looking for donors and raising money. That’s time that we could be better spent on value-creating activities.
For us, there’s also a bit of pride involved. We want to build something without having to constantly asking for money. By building a business model that can stand on its own, we can start and grow a project that has a lasting impact without having to rely on external donors.
Profits are not evil
Something that I’ve personally encountered is that “profit” is associated with “evil”. It brings to mind unethical corporations and greed. Totally fair. Many companies have taken some very questionable and morally dubious actions in the name of profits.
For Red Gold of Afghanistan, we see profits as a path to independence and sustainability. They allow us to continue improving the lives of Afghan women.
Profits allow us to hire trainers to teach more Afghan women about how to grow and harvest saffron.
They let us market the saffron, allowing us to buy more from these Afghan women.
They allow us to attract talented designers and entrepreneurs, who help us grow the business.
Profits = Social good :)
Interested in Making a Difference?
We’re excited about the road ahead, and we’ve just launched our preorders for our premium afghan saffron. Our founder Nazaneen travelled to Herat, Afghanistan this past November, where she met directly with 7 female saffron farmers.
Red Gold partnered with the Ministry of Agriculture, sponsoring training for these women that taught them how to increase the quality of the saffron that they were harvesting. We can’t buy all their saffron, but we know that they will be able to get more for their saffron with this new training.
The premium handpicked Afghan saffron we bought from these women is now ready for preorder! If you’re looking for an amazing gift for someone who loves to cook, or want to spice up a dish with saffron, you can’t go wrong with some of the highest quality saffron in the world.
Not sure how to use saffron? We’ll include some amazing recipes that we’ve found to make sure that you get the most out of your saffron.
86 comments
Srdačan pozdrav svima koji čitaju ovu poruku i želim da znate da ova poruka nije slučajna ili slučajna. Kao uvod, iz Zagreba sam i nisam mogao vjerovati kako sam dobio kredit od 200.000,00 eura. Ponovno sam sretan i financijski stabilan i hvala Bogu što takve kreditne tvrtke još uvijek postoje. Znam da prevaranata ima posvuda i bio sam žrtva prijevare prije dok nisam upoznao ovu pouzdanu tvrtku koja mi je pokazala sve što trebam znati o kreditima i ulaganjima. Ova tvrtka me savjetovala i pomogla, pa ću savjetovati svima kojima je potreban kredit da iskoriste ovu priliku kako bi se izvukli iz financijskih poteškoća. Možete ih kontaktirati putem e-pošte (hybridalliantcreditunion@gmail.com). Brzo kontaktirajte (hybridalliantcreditunion@gmail.com) danas i ostvarite svoj kredit od njih uz kamatnu stopu od 3%. Obavezno kontaktirajte Alliant Credit Union Company i svi vaši financijski problemi bit će riješeni.
Surađuju s odjelima za procjenu rizika, obradu, financiranje i drugim odjelima. Svaki od ovih timova dolazi s ogromnim bogatstvom znanja. To im omogućuje da steknu više znanja o kreditima i pruže bolje iskustvo članovima. Ostvarite svoju financijsku slobodu od njih danas i zahvalite mi kasnije. Jeste li u dugovima, trebate kredit, brz i pouzdan, ovo je mjesto za dobivanje vjerodostojnih kredita. Nude poslovne kredite, studentske kredite, stambene kredite, osobne kredite itd. Kamatna stopa kredita je 3%. Kontaktirajte nas danas. Imate priliku dobiti gotovinski kredit u iznosu od 2000 (€$£) – 5.000.000 – 100.000.000 (€$£) s mogućnostima otplate od 1 godine do 45 godina bez jamstva za nekretnine. Viber: +385915608706
WhatsApp: +385915608706
E-pošta: hybridalliantcreditunion@gmail.com
© 2025 Alliant Credit Union
Web stranica: https://www.alliantcreditunion.org
11545 W. Touhy Ave., Chicago, IL 60666
Broj usmjeravanja: 271081528
Are you searching for a real spell caster ?
It is amazing how quickly Dr. Excellent brought my husband back to me. My name is Heather Delaney. I married the love of my life Riley on 10/02/15 and we now have two beautiful girls Abby & Erin, who are conjoined twins, that were born 07/24/16. My husband left me and moved to be with another woman. I felt my life was over and my kids thought they would never see their father again. I tried to be strong just for the kids but I could not control the pains that tormented my heart, my heart was filled with sorrows and pains because I was really in love with my husband. I have tried many options but he did not come back, until i met a friend that directed me to Dr. Excellent a spell caster, who helped me to bring back my husband after 11hours. Me and my husband are living happily together again, This man is powerful, Contact Dr. Excellent for any kind of spiritual problems or any kind of spell or relationship problems, he is capable of making things right for you. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to work with the best spell caster. Here his contact. Call/WhatsApp him at: +2348084273514 "Or email him at: Excellentspellcaster@gmail.com ,For more information visit his website:https://drexcellentspellcaster.godaddysites.com
I had nearly given up hope after losing access to my cryptocurrency due to a scam, but then I found APEX INTERVENTION LTD—and I’m so glad I did. From the very beginning, their team was professional, responsive, and knowledgeable. They took the time to explain the recovery process clearly and kept me informed every step of the way.
What impressed me most was their technical expertise and persistence. Within a reasonable timeframe, they successfully recovered my lost crypto assets—something I thought was impossible. Their service was not only effective but also handled with integrity and transparency.
If you’ve lost access to your crypto and need a trustworthy and experienced recovery team, I highly recommend APEX INTERVENTION LTD. They turned a stressful situation into a positive outcome, and I’ll always be grateful for their help.
Contact:
Email: info@apex-intervention.online
WhatsApp: +1 (365) 740-5227
Website: https://apex-intervention.online
My daughter had warned me multiple times about the risks of crypto scams, but I never imagined I would fall victim to one. It all started when I came across an ad on YouTube for an “Ethereum mining pool” that promised high returns with minimal effort. The idea of passive income was too tempting, and I didn’t think twice. Unfortunately, what I believed was a legitimate investment opportunity turned out to be a sophisticated scam. I lost 18 ETH my entire retirement savings. The regret and despair I felt were overwhelming. It wasn’t just the money, but the fear of how I would secure my future. I had no idea how to get it back or even where to start. That’s when a friend recommended CHAINTRACE ASSET RECOVERY. At first, I was skeptical. After all, I had already lost so much, and I had no idea who could help me now. But after contacting them, I was surprised at how understanding and patient they were with my situation. They assured me they had the tools and expertise to trace my lost funds, and I decided to give them a chance. CHAINTRACE ASSET RECOVERY did exactly what they promised. Not only did they track down the funds, but they also uncovered the full scope of the scam operation. It was a complex network, involving multiple players across borders. The team worked tirelessly, collaborating with international exchanges and law enforcement to identify the culprits and retrieve as much of my money as possible. In the end, they recovered 17 ETH 94% of what I had lost. What truly impressed me was their professionalism and compassion. They didn’t just treat me like another case; they treated me like a person. When they learned I was a retiree, they even waived part of their fee, which was an incredibly kind gesture. I was beyond grateful for their support and expertise throughout the process. If you’ve fallen victim to a crypto scam, don’t give up hope. CHAINTRACE ASSET RECOVERY. WHATSAPP +1 (581) 256‑1989 WEBSITE: https:/chaintraceassetrecovery.com EMAIL: chaintraceasset@post.com TELEGRAM :https://t.me/CHAINTRACE_ASSET_RECOVERY are miracle workers with hearts of gold. They not only recovered my funds but also gave me a sense of closure and peace of mind. I highly recommend them to anyone facing a similar situation.
At the end of 2024, I made what I thought was a smart move investing £150,000 into a promising crypto opportunity. It looked legitimate, the returns were enticing, and everything seemed perfect until it wasn’t.The withdrawals stopped. The support lines went dead. My account showed a balance, but I couldn’t touch a single pound. That’s when the truth hit me: I had been scammed.I was devastated. It felt like my entire future had just collapsed. Then, someone recommended Washington Recovery Pro and that was the turning point.From the first call, their professionalism and knowledge stood out. They carefully traced the blockchain movements, gathered solid evidence, and guided me through every legal and technical step needed to fight back. It wasn’t an overnight miracle, but their dedicated work brought real results.Thanks to Washington Recovery Pro, I recovered a major portion of my lost funds. More importantly, I got back a sense of control, confidence, and peace of mind.I can’t thank them enough. If you’ve been a victim of crypto fraud, don’t give up hope. These people know what they’re doing and they fight for you when it feels like no one else will.Reach out to them via their handle below.
Email~ WashingtonRecoveryPro@engineer.comWhatsApp ~ +1 (903) 249‑8633Telegram ~ https://t.me/Washingtonrecoverypro